The Making of a New Christmas Eve Dinner Tradition

TasteBud A and I will be spending Christmas eve together this year.  It will be the first time we will be spending it together, so it is our opportunity to start a tradition.  Since Christmas eve will be riddled with last minute shoppers and restaurant servers who would rather be home with their families, we’ve chosen to create the tradition of cooking a Christmas Eve meal together.

When discussing the menu, we wanted to avoid flavors that would inevitably be on our plates the following day.  After our wonderful Fall Wine Exchange at Cornerstone in Apsinwall, we decided to use one of their menu options as inspiration and select a seafood stew. Since a close friend has already attempted to recreate the Cornerstone entrée with positive results, we decided to use the online recipe for Cioppino she found as a base.

Cioppino comes from the San Francisco area and is a recipe derived from traditional Italian flavors.  It’s name comes from the broken english phrase “chip-in” as fishermen were encouraged to contribute ingredients to the stew served at the docks.  It is basically made from a mixture of “catch of the day” fish, so the specific fishes used will vary from chef to chef.  Learning this, I decided that we have the proper leeway to make this tradition our own.

While doing some research into other traditional Christmas eve meals, I discovered that the Feast of Seven Fishes is a traditional Italian Christmas eve meal.  Seeing this inspired me – no, it challenged me – to incorporate seven fishes into the recipe.  So I started looking for other recipes for Cioppino and found a great website that has 20 different recipes.  The broth of this recipe is positioned to be amazing, so a nice crusty bread will accompany the meal.

For those that follow the adventures of the Pittsburgh TasteBuds, I encourage you to “chip in” and comment back with your Christmas and Christmas eve traditions.  For now, I’m headed grocery shopping for the ingredients to my personally modified recipe and will report the results on Christmas Day.

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "The Making of a New Christmas Eve Dinner Tradition"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
5 years 1 month ago

My family has done an abridged version of the 7 fishes since I can remember. They are specific fishes prepared specific ways. The best by far is squid spaghetti. My mother/grandma parboils the squid then drops it in homemade sauce for the last 30 min. It is the best thing in the world, tomorrow can't come soon enough!

5 years 1 month ago

I'm a little too nervous to cook squid. I will be posting the recipe I used shortly, so you can let me know what you think of the Seven fishes that we chose this year.

But, for now, I'll tell you that the dish was a success!


[…] the broth for our Christmas Eve Cioppino simmers, we sit on the couch reminiscing over the past year. The TasteBuds have now celebrated 19 […]


[…] Cioppino that TasteBudA and I have adopted as our Christmas Eve tradition.  The only remnant was The Making of a Christmas Eve Dinner Tradition. I’m puzzled. I have taken pictures of our Cioppino each and every year.  Have I been […]